4 Comments
User's avatar
TWR's avatar

So because garbage populist JD Vance got fewer internet points than garbage populist Zohran Mamdani you think that the internet doesn’t enable populists? These aren’t detailed policy debates. These are two ends of the horseshoe using pre-literate communication to make emotional arguments. This is not good for democracy just because the team whose shirt you like is currently winning over loud idiots online.

Jacob Mchangama's avatar

If you bother reading the piece you’ll see it includes more examples than the one highlighted by you…

TWR's avatar

I read it, I just didn’t want to write a repetitive point-by-point refutation. Everything else you cite is also a meme war, with the possible exception of the Hungarian revolt against Orban, which spent years doing groundwork to build an organization. But if you want one more: I also prefer Scott Colom and think the ad he ran was genius. It’s not a policy argument, though, and he has no idea how to make steak cheaper. He didn’t even pretend to. It’s all propaganda and populist slop with no solutions but lots of blame.

Jacob Mchangama's avatar

Hungary is a pretty big exception. Serbia fits that model too. I could also have added my previous piece on how community notes exposed the Trump admin’s narrative around the killing of Alex Pretti in ways that would have been impossible in the age of analogue.